Best Mini Split Brands

Home/Gas furnaces

The best gas furnace brands, ranked

Five furnace makers judged on their top model's rated efficiency, how finely it modulates, and what the warranty actually covers after the registration deadline passes.

Every brand here makes a condensing furnace in the high nineties for AFUE, so the rating barely separates them. The real differences are how smoothly the burner follows the weather, which parts are covered for how long, and how fast you have to register before the warranty shrinks to five years. Carrier comes out on top by pairing 98.5 percent AFUE with a lifetime heat exchanger and one-percent modulation. Rheem has the broadest warranty. Lennox has the highest efficiency number. Honestly, a correctly sized furnace put in by a careful installer matters more than the badge on the cabinet.

1

Carrier

Best overall

The Infinity 98 (59MN7) is rated up to 98.5 percent AFUE. Paired with Carrier's Infinity control, it adjusts output in one-percent steps. The variable-speed blower helps with dehumidifying in summer, too.

Register on time and you get a lifetime limited warranty on the heat exchanger, plus a choice of ten years parts-only or five years parts with three years labor. Carrier says some sizes meet ENERGY STAR's northern threshold of 97 percent and above.

Watch out: Miss the 90-day registration window and parts coverage falls to five years.

Carrier Infinity 98 page
2

Rheem

Broadest warranty

The Endeavor Line Prestige R98MV is rated 98 percent AFUE and ENERGY STAR certified. A modulating gas valve and variable-speed motor let it run anywhere from 40 to 100 percent of capacity.

Its warranty goes furthest of any here. You get a limited lifetime heat exchanger, ten years on parts, and a limited lifetime conditional unit replacement.

Watch out: The unit replacement is conditional and you have to register. Read the certificate before you count on it.

Rheem R98MV page
3

Lennox

Highest rated efficiency

The Dave Lennox Signature Collection SLP99V is rated up to 99 percent AFUE, the highest number in this ranking, and modulates in small steps. Lennox calls it the quietest furnace you can buy and credits its SilentComfort technology and fully insulated cabinet.

It's ENERGY STAR qualified and dual-fuel capable, with a ten-year limited warranty on covered components.

Watch out: Lennox lists heat exchanger cover as 20-year or lifetime depending on the option, and its page doesn't spell out registration terms. Ask for the certificate that applies to your install.

Lennox SLP99V page
4

Trane

Best-built heat exchanger

Trane's 96 Modulating Variable Speed furnace is rated 97.3 percent AFUE. The 97 Two-Stage Variable Speed model, at 97 percent, uses stainless steel for both heat exchangers, primary and secondary. It also has an insulated cabinet and the Vortica II blower to keep it quiet.

Register within 60 days and Trane's furnace parts warranty is ten years in most cases.

Watch out: Skip registering and parts cover is five years. The product pages don't state heat exchanger terms, so confirm them before you buy.

Trane furnace line-up
5

Goodman

Best two-stage option

Goodman's two-stage GRVT96 is rated up to 97.5 percent AFUE, a hair above its own modulating GRVM97 at up to 97 percent. Both use variable-speed ECM blowers and ComfortBridge controls.

Goodman gives a lifetime limited warranty on the heat exchanger for as long as you own the home. Register within 60 days and parts cover goes from five years to ten. Select models add a ten-year unit replacement.

Watch out: Unit replacement is on select models only. If you live in California, Florida, Georgia or Quebec, you get the registered-owner terms without registering.

Goodman 90%+ furnace range

What AFUE tells you

AFUE is the share of your gas that ends up as heat in the house over a season. Trane notes that 80 percent is the lowest AFUE the Department of Energy currently allows. Going from 80 to 97 percent means roughly 17 fewer cents of every gas dollar go up the flue. The catch: a condensing furnace also needs a condensate drain and plastic venting that an older 80 percent unit didn't.

Modulating, two-stage or single-stage

A single-stage burner is either full on or off. Two-stage adds a lower setting for mild days. A modulating furnace goes further and trims the flame in small steps (one percent at a time on the Carrier, anywhere from 40 to 100 percent on the Rheem). Rooms stay more even and the furnace runs longer, gentler cycles. The efficiency gain between the three is small. You're paying for comfort.

Common questions

Which gas furnace brand is most reliable?

No manufacturer publishes failure rates, so any reliability ranking is opinion. You can compare warranties, though. Carrier, Rheem and Goodman all offer lifetime heat exchanger cover (Carrier's if you register on time), and Rheem adds a conditional lifetime unit replacement. How well it's installed, sized and maintained decides more of a furnace's life than the brand.

Do I have to register a furnace warranty?

Usually, yes, and fast. Carrier gives you 90 days. Trane and Goodman give you 60. Miss it and parts coverage generally drops from ten years to five. Some states and provinces extend registered terms automatically, so check the certificate.

Is a 98 percent furnace worth it over a 96 percent one?

On efficiency alone, the difference is two percent of your heating gas bill. Pay more for modulation and a quieter variable-speed blower instead. Those change how the house feels, not what the meter reads.